Explore BrainMass

Legal Research

Legal research involves finding primary sources of law such as relevant legislation, case law and decisions of administrative tribunals, and verifying that the law found is still valid; that is, that it hasn’t been overruled, repealed or otherwise questioned or criticized. The process for verifying primary sources of law is called “noting up,” such as “noting up a case” or “noting up legislation.” Noting up is also a good way to find other cases dealing with similar aspects of the law.

Students often begin their legal research by consulting secondary sources of the law, such as textbooks, journal articles, encyclopedias, and other reference tools. These secondary sources are a great place to start since they provide a broad overview and explanation of the law and include a number or references to primary sources based on the topic being researched. Secondary sources may also be referenced by a student doing legal research; however, its important to remember that secondary sources may have some persuasive value but are not binding on courts. As a result, when presenting your legal research, it is preferable to cite primary sources of law you have found, rather than the secondary sources you used to get there.

When conducting legal research, it is important to remember that both print and online research resources may contain valuable information on your topic. For example, a legal treatise is a textbook publication with all of the law relating to a particular topic summarized. These textbooks are a great, time-saving secondary resource, but are typically only found in print. Older cases are often only found in print as well. Conversely, on-line resources are often more up-to-date than their print equivalents. Thus its important to know when to use one source over the other.

The most typical legal research involves taking a legal problem presented by a client (or professor) and answering the problem by determining, through research, how the courts are most likely to decide the problem. When presenting legal research, we often follow the five-step legal research process known as F-I-L-A-C: Facts, Issue, Law, Analysis, and Conclusion.(1)


Facts: The first part of any legal research writing assignment should begin with a quick overview of the relevant facts that have been posed in the legal question you are trying to answer.

Issue: The second part of any legal research writing assignment should identify, from the facts of the case, the main legal issues to be determined. Legal issues are normally more narrow than the legal problem as a whole, and relate to one set of facts or area of the law that may be disputed. For example, you might be asked to answer a question such as “did our client have reasonable grounds to dismiss the employee?” or “should the Crown charge the defendant with murder or voluntary manslaughter?” The issue should be posed as a question.

Law: The third part of any legal research writing assignment should present all the primary (and perhaps secondary) sources of law which you have found and you believe to be relevant to the legal issue. This should especially include relevant statutes and case law.

Analysis: The fourth section of your assignment should be the application of the law you have found to the facts of the problem. This application of the law to the facts should allow you to answer the question of how the Courts are likely to solve the legal issue at hand. No new law or facts (other than what has been identified in the previous sections) should be introduced here.

Conclusion: The last section of your assignment should be a brief conclusion. Here you should identify how the Courts are going to rule on the issue you have researched and why, by briefly referring to your analysis.

(1) The FILAC method is developed by Maureen Fitzgerald in her book Legal Problem Solving: Reasoning, Research & Writing (5th ed).

Secondary and tertiary legal sources

Assume that you are in the TA position from the Module Five short paper and have been asked to provide your expertise once again. This time, you have been asked to discuss some of the benefits, and possible concerns, associated with using secondary and tertiary legal sources in a paper. The instructor wants the explanation to be

Research Paper: The O.J. Simpson Trial

Research paper on the O.J. Simpson case. Please help provide ideas and research for the O.J. Simpson case and examine the jury selection process, jury sequestration, jury verdict and the controversies relevant to the jury verdict.

Socioeconomic factors impact on juveniles and gang activity

In using the research topic How does socioeconomic factors contribute to the emergence of youth gangs? •Consider the possible stakeholders for this research topic. Who are they? •What social, political, or personal factors might influence the direction of your research for this topic? •What interest groups would be inv

Inductive, deductive, grounded, and axiomatic theories

What are the key differences between the 4 identified types of research theories (deductive inductive, grounded, and axiomatic)? Is any one type of theory more valid than the others? Why or why not? What are the differences and similarities (if any) between theory and hypothesis? What are variables, and why are they importan

Data collection in criminal justice

I need help researching and describing 5 data collection techniques. Be sure to cite any sources used in APA format. Answer the following questions: Why is the examination of collected data so important? How are statistics used in the field of criminal justice?

Identify the five different discovery devices

Identify the five different discovery devices. Explain what is the purpose of each device? Which discovery device do you think would be the most useful in your case assigned in this class.

The Legal Research Methodology of Cartwheeling

If am having trouble with this question since this is a new technique I am learning. The "cartwheel" is a technique designed to assist paralegals in acquiring the skill of using indexes and tables of contents in law books. The "cartwheel" is a method of developing the habit of phrasing every word involved in the client's

Case Briefing

Brief the following case in one page: HEIRS OF F.D. GOZA, Jr., et al., Appellants v ESTATE OF William E. POTTS, Deceased, Appellee

Memorandum on IT training for employees.

To be most productive in a law office today, each user of the office computer system must be trained in the features and procedures for that system. Imagine you are a Paralegal writing to your boss, the Supervising Partner of the law firm. Write a memorandum of no more than two pages in length, detailing the necessary proced

Understanding the Purposes of Research

Describe the four major purposes of research. Through this, you will show your understanding of the various types of social-science research by defining and describing each of the following four main research purposes: 1. Exploratory 2. Descriptive 3. Explanatory 4. Application (Evaluative and Policy Analysis) In a minimu

Brandi the Blackbear

Consider the attached case study. How do the courts normally notify a person that he or she must report for jury duty? What happens if that person ignores the notice? What is the structure of your state's courts? What is the reasoning for their arrangement in that way?

Criminal Restraint Case Law

Janet Duran was shopping at Shoptown, a local grocery store. She thought she needed only a few items so she didn't get a grocery cart. As she shopped she realized she needed another item, and her hands being full, she put the extra item, nail polish, in her coat pocket. Later she realized she didn't need the polish and put it ba

Legal Memorandums

In supporting an attorney, a paralegal has an ethical responsibility to assist the attorney in his or her zealous representation of a client. In order to be successful, the paralegal must be precise and thorough in the research and analysis and in conveying the results in an office legal memorandum. Can you help me discuss

Legal Writing

Discuss the differences and similarities in writing to the following different audiences: To the court To the opposing attorney To the client To your supervising attorney To a new paralegal who was assigned to help you with a case

Law case review - FLSA

1. "Employers should not ignore employees starting work early, staying beyond scheduled hours, or coming in to work on days off." In regard to the FLSA and compensable time, explain the legal rationale for having such a policy in place. Why is ignoring those behaviors a dangerous policy? 2. Would you suggest that a company offe

Morality in present-day media

Please answer each work separately. Thank you! Topic #1 In our society, we encounter moral questions every day. Television shows and films commonly present characters who must face moral dilemmas and choose a course of action. You can see this in both dramas and sitcoms, like "Dexter," "Law & Order," "The Office," ""Scandal,"

Paralegal Case Study

Although paralegals can play a vital role in the legal team, they also must always comply with ethical limits on their participation. I am the paralegal and what do I do in this case. You have worked closely with her and have been able to assist her by reading documents to her, and by reminding her of matters she has been for

Obtaining and Executing Search Warrants

Scenario You are a special agent with the computer crime center of South Carolina's State Law Enforcement Division (SLED). You recently received a referral from the Aiken County Sheriff's Office regarding a suspect, Bobby Brown, who traveled from Columbia, South Carolina to Aiken, South Carolina to meet a minor female to engage