Share
Explore BrainMass

Belief & Truth

Sometimes, there is a gap between what we believe to be true and what is actually true and in many cases, this can be hard to prove or argue. When that belief is one which is strong and paramount to a person’s very identity - religion being the most obvious of instance of this - serious issues can arise when it comes into conflict with another’s similar belief. For this reason, as well as for its intellectual value, the question of what constitutes truth and belief, particularly concerning when a belief can be justified and considered truth, is an important one.

The Crusades lasted almost 200 years with a conservative estimate for casualties being 200,000 for the crusading side alone1.

A related area that benefits from a critical analysis is that of knowledge, or epistemology. There remains much discussion on the steps between truth, belief and knowledge. One contemporary idea begins soundly with the basis that, in accordance with our logic system, a belief can be either true or false. In this case, a true belief is a truth and the final step from there to knowledge is justification of that belief. False beliefs here are at best troublesome and should be discarded. However, there are other lines of thought which find this endorsement of beliefs counterproductive - Plato’s Socrates goes so far as to call them “shameful”2 - and these thinkers would have us construct knowledge with a far heavier leaning on evidence than hypothesised beliefs. The fact that something can be true and not believed (consider those who doubted tectonic shift or anyone griever who has remarked that they ‘can’t bring themselves to believe’ a loved one is lost) supports their cause but ground has also been gained by chasing a belief (see the concept of scientific intuition, or any forerunner like DaVinci who designed flying machines based on the belief that humans would fly one day). The argument continues to this day.

Diagram of one of DaVinci's ideas for a flying machine

 

References:

1. History Rocket (). How Many Died in the Crusades?. [ONLINE] Available at: www.historyrocket.com/World-War/crusades/How-Many-Died-In-The-Crusades.html. [Last Accessed 5é2é14].
2. Vogt, Katja M., (2012). Belief and Truth: A Skeptic Reading of Plato. 1st ed. New York: Oxford University Press.

Categories within Belief & Truth

Justified True Belief

Postings: 4

This section looks at the requirements for a belief to be considered justified and how this relates to the idea of true knowledge.

Ethical Relativism: Social Context versus Object Truth

People of different cultures engage in different practices and espouse divergent notions about what is right and wrong. What does this tell us about our own ethical commitments? Do all values depend solely upon the social context from which they emerge, or are there objective truths upon which we might all agree? Use specific ex

Theories of Truth

The introduction to this unit identified four distinct approaches to our understanding of truth: - Correspondence theory - Coherence theory - Pragmatic theory - Cognitive relativism Think of a statement about ordinary life whose truth conditions seem to fit best naturally with one of these approaches in particular. Expl

Identifying a Belief

(1) Identify a decision about which reasonable minds can disagree; (2) explain the nature of belief and identify the beliefs and values that informed the decision that was made; (3) explain a relevant theory of human freedom, consciousness, and/or reality; (4) analyze how the chosen theory might approach the decision, including

) In your words, what is James' theory of truth? Using James' theory, assess the truth of the statement "the world is flat" for a traveler in the 5 th century. 2) What two personality types did James identify? How did he characterize them? Which one did he see as more realistic and which did he consider better for us psychologically? Do you agree with James?

1) In your words, what is James' theory of truth? Using James' theory, assess the truth of the statement "the world is flat" for a traveler in the 5th century. James uses the words "truth" in the same way that most of us use the word "useful" today. Essentially he taught that if a belief was useful or if it "worked" then

Truth

Discuss each of the following: James - Truth is personal Wittgenstein's Tractatus Heidegger's Burden of Being Human

Rhetoric & Stereotypes

I needed stereotypes example associated with the groups below. (1) Politicians, (2) Tattooed Persons, (3) Feminists, (4) Senior Citizens. Discuss the stereotypes associated with each of these groups. Provide an explanation of whether these groups invoke the same image to all persons, and if the stereotypes are positive, neg

William James's View's on Truth

1. Something is true as long as it is practical to believe so. 2. Idea of practical implications: An idea only has meaning in so far as it has practical implication. What does it mean? Could you explain it for me, using some examples from our everyday life for each statement. Thank you.