Share
Explore BrainMass

Merton's Strain Theory

Robert K. Merton’s Strain Theory falls within structural functionalism, which points to the stable or unstable structure of society and its normative ethics as a leading factor in rates of deviance.

According to Strain theorists, deviance within society is a result of the structure of society itself. Merton assumes that all members of society, across all socioeconomic statuses share common values and goals, like being able to own your house, have a car, enjoy holidays, etc.¹

In reality, not everyone is in the same economic or social position to realize these goals. In a society that is not actually meritocratic, there are social groups that do not have an equal opportunity to be successful in these common goals.

In the United States, the ‘American Dream’ is the philosophy that anyone, regardless of background can achieve success if they are willing to work. This idea is operating under the assumption that everyone has equal opportunity.¹ Merton argues that this is not actually true and that the pressure from society to achieve this American Dream pushes individuals to deviance. Essentially, the acquisition of wealth is a dominant cultural goal in the US but legitimate means of achieving this are not uniformly distributed.¹

In Merton’s words, “this social and cultural structure generates pressure for socially deviant behaviour upon people variously located in that structure.”¹ This strain may be either structural or individual. Structural strains are the processes at the societal level that affect someone's perception of their needs. Individual strains are the pains experienced by someone as they look for ways to satisfy their needs.

Merton outline Five Models of Adaptation that people use in response to their strains¹:

  1. Conformity
  2. Innovation
  3. Retreatism
  4. Ritualism
  5. Rebellion

Criticisms of Strain Theory include that a lot of crime is not utilitarian but malicious and therefore not applicable under this theory.¹ It also fails to explain youth crimes that people engage in for status instead of acquisition.

 

 

Reference:

1. Strain Theory. Retrieved May 8, 2014, from http://socialscience.stow.ac.uk/criminology/criminology_notes/strain_theory.htm

Robert Merton Theory

Part A 1. There are three independent yet overlapping branches within the social structure. perspective social disorganization theory, strain theory, and culture conflict theory. Discuss the. main focuses of each of these theories (and by 'main focuses" l mean the basic premise of. each theory, assumptions about crime causation

The Strain Perspective

The Strain Perspective In Chapter 4, we studied the strain perspective and noticed that the concept of the American Dream was a central component to this perspective's argument. Policy implications for this perspective focused on changing the structure of society or de-emphasizing the importance of achieving monetary success

Structural Functionalism: Merton's Analysis

Can you please help me understand the weaknesses of Merton's analysis of dysfunction (including latent and manifest functions)? Is there an alternative? Like integrative conflict theory?