Explore BrainMass

Explore BrainMass

    Moral Judgments, Moral beliefs and Logical Rules

    This content was COPIED from BrainMass.com - View the original, and get the already-completed solution here!

    We've been having some trouble figuring out how we arrive at moral
    judgments. Cultural Relativism, Supernaturalism, Intuitionism, Rationalism.
    all seem to have their good points, but also their undermining bad points.
    Then what do you say to picking out our moral principles by trying to be
    informed and imaginative, and then seeing what we can consistently hold?
    Even if our moral beliefs can't be provable from facts, perhaps we could
    take the positions that "we ought to do this" as a universalizable
    prescription, and then add: "Do this and let everyone do the same in
    similar cases."

    Agree? Disagree? Why?

    And then consider logical "rules" that might go along with this position?
    For instance, we must be logically consistent, right? To be so, must we not
    make similar evaluations about similar cases? And also, to be do so, must
    we not keep our moral beliefs in harmony with how we live and want others to
    live? Do any others come to mind?

    © BrainMass Inc. brainmass.com June 3, 2020, 9:45 pm ad1c9bdddf
    https://brainmass.com/business/business-law/moral-judgments-moral-beliefs-logical-rules-197864

    Solution Preview

    Hi,

    Excellent debate questions! Let's take a closer look.

    RESPONSE:

    1. We've been having some trouble figuring out how we arrive at moral judgments. Cultural Relativism, Supernaturalism, Intuitionism, Rationalism all seem to have their good points, but also their undermining bad points. Then what do you say to picking out our moral principles by trying to be informed and imaginative, and then seeing what we can consistently hold? Even if our moral beliefs can't be provable from facts, perhaps we could take the positions that "we ought to do this" as a universalizable prescription, and then add: "Do this and let everyone do the same in similar cases." Agree? Disagree? Why?

    Have you given this some thought? Let's disagree as a case in point.

    In theory, this might work. However, even though research has found certain values to be universal, there are still individual differences to account for in every culture. How would we make people behave in a universally accepted way? I guess that is where laws come into play. In fact, our present laws are in fact, at least some of them, are universal in prescription, such as it I wrong to murder someone. However, there are differences across cultures in terms of exceptions to the rule or a law. For ...

    Solution Summary

    This solution discusses how a person derives at moral judgments using various theories, such as "we ought to do this" as a universalizable prescription, and then add: "Do this and let everyone do the same in similar cases." It then discusses logical "rules" that might go along with this position.

    $2.19

    ADVERTISEMENT