Explore BrainMass
Share

Formulating an argument to support your position

This content was STOLEN from BrainMass.com - View the original, and get the already-completed solution here!

It is snowing. Two people drive home from work in opposite directions down country roads. Both slide in the snow, and run off the road. The first person, when she slides, runs into a mailbox. The other person runs into a child.

Assume that both drivers weren't impaired in any way (e.g., not drunk, not distracted, etc.).

(A) Are both drivers' actions equally morally excusable? Why or why not?

(B) Construct an argument to support your position on the case.

(C) Reflect on what your answers in (A) and (B) reveal about the value of intent in determining the moral worth of a given action.

© BrainMass Inc. brainmass.com October 25, 2018, 5:52 am ad1c9bdddf
https://brainmass.com/philosophy/ethics-morals/formulating-argument-support-your-position-437961

Solution Preview

Both drivers are equally morally excusable because the intent of both the drivers was not wrong. Further, both of them were not impaired in any way. Thus, it was by mere chance or circumstances beyond the control of both these drivers that one of them ran into a mailbox and other one ...

Solution Summary

It is snowing. Two people drive home from work in opposite directions down country roads. Both slide in the snow, and run off the road. The first person, when she slides, runs into a mailbox. The other person runs into a child.

Assume that both drivers weren't impaired in any way (e.g., not drunk, not distracted, etc.).

(A) Are both drivers' actions equally morally excusable? Why or why not?

(B) Construct an argument to support your position on the case.

(C) Reflect on what your answers in (A) and (B) reveal about the value of intent in determining the moral worth of a given action.

$2.19
See Also This Related BrainMass Solution

Philosophy help

I have formulated my own questions (listed on top). If you could point out the main arguments, premises, conclusion of those main arguments. Basically, I need help answering those questions that ive listed at the top as detailed as possible as it help me out.

View Full Posting Details