Theorem: Suppose that a sequence S of real numbers has a subsequence that converges to a real number a. Then S converges to a.

I know this is true as an if and only if statement, but I need a counter example to show that just one converging subsequence isn't enough.

Here are two sequences I'm considering: {1,-1,1,-1,1,-1...).
Another is {0, 1,1/2, 1/3, ..., 1/n}.

Our definition of a subsequence is: Let S={(n,an(subscript)}be a sequence of real numbers. A subsequence of S is a sequence T formed as follows:
1) Let theta be a function with domain the counting numbers and range contained in the counting numbers, and such that theta(n)>theta(m) whenever n>m.
2) T ={(m,a(theta(me)(subscript).
To specify a subsequence, you must specify the function theta.

Here's where I need help:
1) How do I develop a subsequence from one of the sequences I have. (If you have a simpler sequence, please suggust using it). What is the domain, range, and the function theta?

2) How do I show convergence? I know that I pick an r, but then what? I need to show how both S and T converge and that they don't converge to the same point.

Thanks!

Solution Preview

I will go ahead with your sequences.
First, we should understand that subsequence is a part of the given sequence. For the sequence you have considered above, we can list out few subsequences as {1, 1, 1, 1, 1, .....} or {-1, -1, -1, -1, -1, .....} or {1, -1, 1, 1, -1, 1, 1, 1, -1, 1, 1, 1, 1, -1.....}. A subsequence must be defined on its own but its elements must be from the parent sequence ...

... Show that it has two convergent subsequences which converge to distinct limit points. ... Convergent subsequences are contemplated in this solution. ...

... or argue that such a request is impossible: 1) A sequence that does not contain 0,1 as a term but contains subsequences converging to each of these values. ...

... set of extended real numbers, and prove that if a sequence of extended real numbers is such that each of its subsequences has a subsequence that converges to x ...

... This question concerns the limits that subsequences of a given infinite sequence of real numbers could converge to, given the condition on the limit superior ...

... It follows that there exists a common subsequence that converges, that is, the subsequences {c_{1,i_k}}_{k},...c_{m,i_k}}_{k} are convergent to numbers c_1 ...

...subsequences of {xn } which converges to two distinct limits. But from the condition, {xn }. has only one accumulation point x , we get a contradiction. ...

...convergent subsequence {z nk } of {zk } , then we can find a convergent subsequence {wnk } . t. Without loss of generality, we rewrite the subsequences back as ...

... of convergence or cauchy or epsilon delta. ... 0 goes to 0 and sin(1/y_n^2) = sin(2npi + pi/2) = 1 goes to 1, then we have two different subsequences that go to ...