Share
Explore BrainMass

public assistance plans

Key Question The following table contains three hypothetical public assistance plans.

Plan I
Earned Income Transfer Payment Total Income
$ 0 $4000 $4000
2000 3000 5000
4000 2000 6000
6000 1000 7000
Plan 2
Earned Income Transfer Payment Total Income
$ 0 $4000 $ 4000
4,000 3000 7,000
8,000 2000 10,000
12,000 1000 13,000
Plan 3
Earned Income Transfer Payment Total Income
$ 0 $8000 $ 8,000
4,000 6000 10,000
8,000 4000 12,000
12,000 2000 14,000

a. Determine the minimum income, the benefit- reduction rate, and the break-even income for each plan.
b. Which plan is the most costly? The least costly? Which plan is the most effective in reducing
poverty? The least effective? Which plan contains the strongest disincentive to work? The weakest disincentive to work?
c. Use your answers in part Ii to explain the following statement: "The dilemma of public assistance is that you cannot bring families up to the poverty level and simultaneously preserve work incentives (without work requirements) and minimize program costs."

Solution Preview

a)
Plan 1:
Minimum income = $4,000;
Benefit-reduction rate = +1000/2000 = 50 percent;
Break-even income = $4000/0.5=$8,000

Plan 2:
Minimum income = $4,000;
Benefit-reduction rate = +1000/4000 = 25 percent;
Break-even income = $4000/0.25=$16,000

Plan 3:
Minimum income = $8,000; ...

Solution Summary

This posting determines the minimum income, the benefit- reduction rate, and the break-even income for each plan.

$2.19