: Ethical Situation #2: Unethical Behavior Memo
You have been hired as the new controller of a large manufacturing company. The 30-year-old company produces a selection of profitable products, but has also experienced some ethical lapses. A few months into your new role, the CEO has asked you to prepare a memo that will provide guidance to management for handling some of these ethical lapses. As you investigate, you discover a negative atmosphere in the company. Your investigation reveals the following information:
CEO: We need to create a way to make sure our company goals are defined and align with the highest ethical standards. We have experienced issues in almost every department, and I am trying to focus on what we can do. I know you have spoken with others, and I suspect there is some unethical behavior occurring. I have heard that the accounting department has experienced some issues in the past. Specifically, issues with fake suppliers being created and paid. While this did result in the termination of one employee, I'm not sure it has stopped.
Accounts Receivable Supervisor: Things are pretty bad around here. There doesn't seem to be any leadership or direction for the company. Upper management rarely conducts meetings to discuss anything, positive or negative. There are no clear goals and we only receive feedback once a year at our annual review. I have difficulty keeping the staff motivated because the meager raises. We all receive the same raise, even in a booming year when sales are high.
Accounts Payable Supervisor: I used to be energetic when I started working here. I suppose this place just wears you down after a while. There doesn't seem to be any correlation between pay and performance. You can be a high performer and receive a 2% raise or be a low performer and receive a 1% raise. Most of the staff have given up, and view their position as a job rather than a career.
Upon further inspection, you discover that the vendor files are in disarray, and there is no proper backup to support the invoice and expense reports that have been paid.
Sales Team Manager: I am having difficulty getting the sales team to visit their accounts and provide acceptable customer service. Part of the problem is that the company has set the commission schedule to prior standards, when sales were easy to acquire. Each salesperson receives only 1% commission on the sales in his or her territory. I am beginning to wonder if they are visiting the existing accounts anymore. Sales are still healthy--no one seems to ask questions when the sales are healthy--but we are not seeing many new sales.?
Explain some of the underlying motives contributing to the unethical behavior.
Recommend a few changes that might alleviate some of the unethical behavior and improve employee morale.
Address the common fraud schemes in the outflow of company funds, including check tampering, payroll schemes, and expense reimbursement schemes.
Suggest several controls for the company to implement in order to prevent these schemes.
This article is written by an author, John C. Dencker, who has research background and the study was conducted using a firm with multiple restructures during the time frame. He has gathered data from numerous sources to include in his findings.
The main goal was to prove that female managers were underrepresented in leadership positions in large firms. His focus was on restructures creating the inequality. The two primary focuses were on the reduction in force and reorganization of human resources as the reason for the failure to promote women to leadership positions. The pressures of inequality during these times have greater opportunities for discrimination. One idea is that reductions in the force slowed promotion rates for all. Two others included women starting in lower-status jobs and women's promotion advantages were often short lived.
To do the ...
Unethical behavior memos are examined. The expert creates a way to make sure our company goals are defined.