Two criteria used to judge the quality of a work: craft (how well an artwork was made) and communication (the uniqueness of the artist's vision and its message or meaning). Michelangelo Buonarroti and Leonardo da Vinci were considered masters of these two qualities. Compare a work of art from each artist using the following for discussion:
Post the images you have selected.
Describe what each work intended to communicate. How does each of the works communicate its message?
Describe SPECIFIC techniques that each artist used to convey meaning. For example: composition, color, perspective, chiaroscuro, idealism, sfumato, gesture, size, symbolism, allegory.
Be sure to identify where these techniques are used in the works you discuss. You may use the Internet to find the artwork.
The attachment includes the images and hyperlinks, which this text box does not. Please open the MS Word 2007 attachment.
The relevant portion of this Web site reference is copied and pasted here for you, including the required image:
The Madonna of the Carnation, ca. 1478-80
Leonardo da Vinci (Italian, 1452-1519)
Leonardo da Vinci (Italian, 1452-1519). The Madonna of the Carnation, ca. 1478-80. Oil on panel. 62 x 47.5 cm (24 3/8 x 18 11/16 in.).
Alte Pinakothek, Munich
Leonardo Status: Madonna of the Carnation spent most of its existence being attributed to Andrea del Verrocchio. Modern scholarship has revised attribution in favor of Leonardo, based on the handling of the drapery and background scenery, the nearly scientific rendering of the carnations in the vase, and overall similarities between this composition and the (undisputed) Benois Madonna.
The content of the Web site resource that is relevant is copied and pasted here for you:
Holy Family with St. John (Doni Tondo)
The Holy Family with Saint John (Doni Tondo) 1506 by Michelangelo Buonarroti, a painting made for Agnolo Doni is the only painting on wood which can be historically attributed to Michelangelo.The unique round frame called a tondo is decorated with the coat of arms of the Strozzi family (the family of the patron's wife Maddalena) and was designed by Michelangelo. This painting was to foment controversy upon its presentation to the Doni family not only for its somber and unique treatment of the holy family (normally Joseph would not be included in such a ...
This solution provides a comparison and contrast of two Renaissance paintings of the Holy Family, one by Michelangelo and one by Da Vinci.