Explore BrainMass
Share

Legal decision making

This content was STOLEN from BrainMass.com - View the original, and get the already-completed solution here!

Question is:

Scholars who have studied approaches to legal decision-making by the judges have classified legal jurisprudence into a number of philosophical schools. Identify and discuss briefly the theoretical approaches to legal decision-making, emphasizing how they differ from each other.

© BrainMass Inc. brainmass.com October 25, 2018, 4:18 am ad1c9bdddf
https://brainmass.com/political-science/political-theory/legal-decision-making-373352

Solution Preview

There are primarily three schools of legal jurisprudence or philosophy of law:

Natural law is the idea that there are rational objective limits to the power of legislative rulers. The foundations of law are accessible through human reason and it is from these preexistent laws of nature that human created laws gain whatever force they have. In that laws may be accessed through human reason, factors such as human values and mores matter a great deal in the process of formulating the law.

By ...

Solution Summary

The solution provides advise to students in the task of understanding theoretical approaches to legal decision making especially the philosophical divisions in relation to how it is practiced.

$2.19
See Also This Related BrainMass Solution

Analyze political, social, ethical and legal differences and their impact on management decision making

Antitrust laws were essentially created to stop businesses that got too large from blocking competition and abusing their power. Mergers and monopolies can limit the choices offered to consumers because smaller businesses are not usually able to compete. Although free and open competition ensures lower prices and new and better products, it has the potential to significantly limit market diversity.

Look at the 2 examples below of how mergers and acquisitions have affected the way in which companies do business.
Read each of the 2 examples below. Decide which one you would like to use for your project and answer the following questions.

- Identify the two firms with similar problems from different countries
- Conduct a comparative analysis of the firms
- Analyze political, social, ethical and legal differences and their impact on management decision making
- Provide substantive conclusion and recommendations

Example 1
Federal antitrust enforcers are investigating whether a multinational pharmaceutical company has attempted to minimize the impact of generic competition to one of its most profitable prescription drugs. This anti-depressant drug is the company's best seller, with sales last year of $2.11 billion, representing a 22% increase from the year before.

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is conducting an investigation to determine whether the company has engaged in activities to prevent generic alternatives to the prescription drug from entering the market. Specifically, the FTC is challenging a practice among brand-name and generic-drug manufacturers to agree to delay the introduction of the lower priced generic drugs to the market.

Answer the following questions:
- Why would the drug maker want to stymie generic competition? Explain.
- What types of legal barriers to market entry exist?
- What are the possible ethical dilemmas present in this example?

Example 2
The boards of 2 major telecommunications companies recently agreed to a $16 billion-dollar merger that would create the world's largest telecommunications company in the world. Although some agree that the synergy between these companies could be dynamic, others feel consumers could ultimately pay the price for the merger depending on which company becomes dominant in the various service areas.

Answer the following questions:
- Why do you think consumer advocates have expressed concern over such merger possibilities?
- Other than pricing, what are some pitfalls that consumers might have to deal with when 2 major companies merge?
- What are the possible ethical dilemmas present in this example?

PART B

Many organizations have established policies to remedy discrimination when hiring women and minorities. Discuss whether you feel that affirmative action programs, reverse discrimination, and criteria of comparable worth are appropriate forms of remedy. Using the textbook, course materials, and Web resources, research affirmative action, reverse discrimination, and comparable worth and answer the following questions:
- Do you feel that these concepts are appropriate forms of remedy in the workplace? Explain.
- What else do you think could be done to eliminate discrimination in the workplace?

View Full Posting Details