Purchase Solution

Mammy stereotypes

Not what you're looking for?

Ask Custom Question

Cultural Images: Discussing a Historical Example of an American Stereotype
The 1923 news item below appeared in the March 3 issue of Time magazine; it concerns a Congressional proposal to honor black women of the Old South.

http://xroads.virginia.edu/~MA99/diller/mammy/fiction.html

Read the news item below and include your reflections and analysis of the following items:

1. What appears to be the attitude of the writer toward "Negro women" in the first paragraph? How does this attitude change in the second paragraph? Why do you think the attitude of the author changes?

2. The proposal for a statue came from Southern legislators, many of who were raised by Black nannies. Given this fact, do you think they were sincere in their proposal to honor the black women by erecting this statue? In your own words, why did the black women reject this proposal? If Congress had erected this statue of "The Black Mammy of the South," how do you think white and black people would view that statue today?

3. What might be a comparable situation today where white people are insisting on maintaining a cultural image for a (nonwhite) group of people? Explain how and why this is a comparable situation.

Purchase this Solution
Solution Summary

Mammy stereotypes are briefly discussed in terms of race and gender subjugation.

Solution Preview

Welcome to BM! Please rate 5/5 for my 400 words of notes to model some ideas. I'm honored to assist you on your future academic endeavors. Your business is valuable to me! Thank you so much for using BrainMass.com!

1. What appears to be the attitude of the writer toward "Negro women" in the first paragraph? How does this attitude change in the second paragraph? Why do you think the attitude of the author changes?

In the first paragraph, the author seems to try and dissect fictionalized versions of the mammy figure through Beecher's portrayal of Aunt Chloe as the author discusses "Stowe's decision to portray Aunt Chloe in a cabin feeding her three children while Uncle Tom and George Shelby looked on did give Aunt Chloe something future mammies often lacked--an implied sex life." It seems at first like the author saw images of mammies as so remote from white families, "world's away" even.

However, the author's attitude changes in the second paragraph to reveal that the mammy depictions were highly ...

Solution provided by:
Stacy Shaneyfelt, MA
Education
  • BS , Slippery Rock University
  • MA, Slippery Rock University
Recent Feedback
  • "thk u"
  • "Thank you. Posted one more.. if you are online pls help. "
  • "thk u"
  • "thk u"
  • "thnk you"
Purchase this Solution
Free BrainMass Quizzes
Research Methods for Data Collection

This quiz is designed for students to help them gain a better understanding of the different types of research and when to appropriately use them.

Sociology: Socialization & Social Groups

A refresher quiz on socialization.

View More Free Quizzes
Related BrainMass Solutions

  • Depiction of black Americans in cinema in 1930s - 1940s

    For example, Davis writes that the film Gone with the Wind, "presented a range of black characters who exemplified various aspects of the accepted racial stereotypes.

  • Media Stereotypes

    Ramasubramanian (2010) insists that African-Americans, for example, "have been portrayed using such despicable stereotypes as the mammy (big, mean, loud mother figure), the coon (lazy, unreliable buffoon), the buck (savage, ruthless brute), and the

  • negative stereotypes

    394692 Holding Negative Stereotypes Do you think people who hold negative stereotypes always know it? You suggest the media could help by decreasing the use of stereotypes, but would that point out to people they are holding these stereotypes?

  • Stereotypes and how they change overtime

    348362 What explains the context of stereotypes? How and why do stereotypes of groups change over time? What explains the context of stereotypes? How and why do stereotypes of groups change over time?

  • Stereotypes and Prejudice: Identification & Definition

    - What are the positive aspects of stereotypes, if any? - What are the negative aspects of stereotypes? Part III Answer each question in 50 to 150 words related to those stereotypes. Provide citations for all the sources you use.

  • Stereotypes

    /GC2000/MODULES/STEREOTYPES/Glossary.htm).

  • Stereotyped Cultures in Movies and TV

    More often than not these routines do not backfire, but help to combat bias and stereotypes by revealing that almost all cultures have stereotypes of other cultures that are not grounded in fact or reality.

  • Source of development of stereotypes

    422273 Source of development of stereotypes Are these statements true? If so, please briefly elaborate on them individually. 1) There are many "causes" to the development of stereotypes.

  • How do you think negative stereotypes can be managed?

    Managing or dismissing negative stereotypes that are directed to an individual or a society can be difficult because some common stereotypes could be considered as universal labels or categories that could be hard to discard.

View More Related Solutions