Explore BrainMass

Controversy Over DSM-5

Can someone help me with a description of the controversy associated with the publication of the DSM-5? Also, can someone help me explain the controversy and how it may influence future professionals in the field?

Solution Preview

As you know, we here at BrainMass cannot do the work for you, but we CAN make your life easier with ideas and sources.
Let me give you a broad overview of the controversies here. There are many of them.

There is a problem with the relation between grieving (loss of a loved one) and depression.

Read here: http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/rethinking-depression/201110/the-dsm-5-controversy
and: http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/side-effects/201202/dsm-5-controversy-is-now-firmly-transatlantic
and: http://www.edutopia.org/blog/dsm-5-adhd-mental-health-mark-phillips

Basic summary and impact:

Bereavement is being given its own "disorder." This means that those who have lost a loved one (and are suffering because of it) will be called "depressives."

"Mild forgetfulness" too, is given its own "disorder" standing.

Fewer symptoms will be needed for ADHD.

There is some movement to change this: http://www.edutopia.org/blog/dsm-5-adhd-mental-health-mark-phillips

The big impact is that the DSM-5 will be used by insurance companies to decide whether diagnoses are genuine. If the criteria are lessened for ADHD, then a) insurance will ...

Solution Summary

The controversy over DSM-5 are examined. How it may influence the future professionals in the field are determined.