Explore BrainMass

The Crime Control Model and the Due Process Model

This content was STOLEN from BrainMass.com - View the original, and get the already-completed solution here!

The Crime Control Model and the Due Process Model obviously have competing values. What common ground do the models share? Where do they disagree the most?

© BrainMass Inc. brainmass.com October 25, 2018, 3:24 am ad1c9bdddf

Solution Preview

Welcome to BrainMass. Thank you for the opportunity of assisting you to do well in your assignment.

There are two models of the criminal process which compete within the process and cause a tension in the criminal justice system. There are underlying values of each and most of the time neither stops to consider the dynamics of the other nor their underlying values. The models are polarities and neither is entirely subscribed to by anyone in the system. There is common ground, however, and assumptions that are shared widely. (Packer, Herbert L. 1968)
The first is that criminals cannot be dealt with until the definition of criminal behavior has been established. One certainly cannot accuse a person of a crime if that crime has not been previously defined. (id)
Secondly, when it is suspected that a crime has been committed and there is reason to believe that the perpetrator can be apprehended the criminal process should be invoked. Of course, it is known that there are times when this process has not been invoked when there has been a crime committed, while there have also been times when the process has been invoked when a crime has not been committed. (id)
Third, the Constitution limits the powers in the criminal justice system to interfere in the lives of the American citizens (e.g. illegal searches and seizures covered by the fourth amendment to the Constitution).
Although there is the right for the accused to participate in his own defense and may insist that the system show to an independent entity (judge and/or jury), it is a permission and not a requirement that the defendant participate. Between the two models there are stronger and/or weaker notions of how the contest now to occur will be arranged. The Crime Control Model would in all probability put less emphasis on the process as being "adversarial," while the Due Process Model would determine the adversarial aspect was central to the process. (id)
Underlying the Crime Control Model is the determination that the most important function in the process is crime prevention. The failure to do so, then, would cause the breakdown of "public order. . . an important condition of human freedom" (id), i.e. the failure to apprehend criminals would subject citizens to victimization and thereby prevent them from having freedom. The necessity to fulfill the goal of crime prevention does, by its very nature, lead to more employment and man-hours in the entire criminal justice process, leading to higher costs. This leads to the necessity of efficiency which has also led to a broader area of behavior to be considered anti-social. This, of course, leads to still higher costs and the public is not necessarily ready to invet in either the quantity or quality of resources to prevent crime.
This model leads to the desire for a high rate of apprehension and conviction and the magnitude is very large, while the resources are very limited. This requires speed and finality. Speed leads ...

Solution Summary

The Crime Control Model and the Due Process Model are contrasted.

See Also This Related BrainMass Solution

Crime Control and Due Process Models

Crime Control and Due Process Models

The crime control and due process models represent opposing views of the purpose of the criminal justice system. The tenets of each model influence all levels of the system from police procedure to correctional policy.

During Earl Warren's term as Chief Justice of the US Supreme Court, the court made several landmark decisions that drastically altered the procedures followed by police and prosecutors. Among these were the decisions handed down in the Mapp, Miranda, Gideon, and Escobedo cases.

Keeping the differences of the two models in mind, prepare a 4 page document in Microsoft Word document which addresses the following points:

Which model is evident in the above-referenced decisions of the Warren Court? Give proper reasoning and also analyze how these decisions can affect police procedures.
What are the significant operational differences between the crime control model and the due process model? Also, how do the police, court, or correctional procedures differ depending on which model is being followed?
Which model seems to be currently in effect in the United States? Explain.
What is the impact of each model on victims of crime? Explain.
Support your responses with examples.

Cite any sources in APA format.

View Full Posting Details