Explore BrainMass
Share

Environmental ethics & economic incentives

This content was STOLEN from BrainMass.com - View the original, and get the already-completed solution here!

In his book, What Price Incentives?, Steven Kelman suggests that from an ethical point of view, the use of economic incentives (such as emission charges or emissions trading) in environmental policy is undesirable. He argues that transforming our mental image of the environment from a sanctified preserve to a marketable commodity has detrimental effects not only on our use of the environment, but also on our attitude toward it. His point is that applying economic incentives to environmental policy weakens and cheapens our traditional values toward the environment.

a. Consider the effects of economic incentive systems on prices paid by the poor, on employment, and on the speed of compliance with pollution control laws as well as the Kelman arguments. Are economic incentive systems more or less ethically justifiable than the traditional regulatory approach?

b. Kelman seems to feel that because emission allowances automatically prevent environmental degradation, they are more ethically desirable than emission charges. Do you agree? Why or why not?

c. If we were to allow the private market to bring about an efficient outcome that society would deem desirable, do you think they would be able to effectively reflect the true market benefit and cost?

© BrainMass Inc. brainmass.com October 17, 2018, 2:59 am ad1c9bdddf
https://brainmass.com/economics/legislation-regulation/environmental-ethics-economic-incentives-404587

Solution Preview

a. Kelman is comparing the impacts of regulation vs. incentives. In effect, regulatory policy says, "Pollute too much and we'll shut down your business." Economic incentives say, "Pollute all you want, but be prepared to pay for it." Kelman argues that the first strategy is more ethically desirable because it sends a clear message that polluting is wrong. You can choose whether to agree or ...

Solution Summary

Steven Kelman, author of What Price Incentives?, argues that the use of economic incentives in environmental policy is undesirable because it cheapens our traditional values toward the environment. This solution presents a contrasting view.

$2.19
Similar Posting

Management Agency Theory and Incentives

Question 1:
Brennan said that the agency theory & incentives will 'coarsen' humanity and make the world we live in a less hospitable place. Do you agree? why or why not, whether your business uses them and if so, whether they work or what you would do differently.

Question 2:
what is altruism and what role does altruism has in business? explain giving appropriate examples.

987 words

View Full Posting Details