Share
Explore BrainMass

Public Accounting Profession

In their review of the public accounting profession, Lou Harris and Associates warn that an audit report too often is viewed as a "certificate of health" for a company: The report states:

The most serious consequences stemming from such a misunderstanding are that the independent auditor can quickly be portrayed as the force that represents all good in financial accounting and the guarantor of anything positive anyone wants to feel about a given company.

1. Why is public accounting often viewed as a guarantor of results or even as a provider of assurance that one's investment is of high quality?
2. To what extent is it reasonable to view the auditor as a guarantor? Explain.
3. How does the auditing profession work to create or communicate a reasonable set of expectations that users should hold?
4. To what extent do you believe that user expectations of the public accounting profession appear to you to be unwarranted? Explain.

Solution Preview

1. Why is public accounting often viewed as a guarantor of results or even as a provider of assurance that one's investment is of high quality?
1. Public accounting is viewed as a guarantor of results or provider of assurance because:
2. Those accounts that have been audited are perceived to be correct, reliable and indicators of a good future performance.
3. The auditor is now required to comment about the quality of management as well as the intentions as perceived by the auditor. So if the public accountant has audited the books of a company it is assumed that the company has good governance.
4. The auditor is expected to maintain objectivity and fairness and so it is expected that the income and revenues are correct.
5. Currently public accountants are required to comment on the internal controls of the company, so if the public accountant gives a good report it is believed that there are excellent internal control measures in place and there is little likelihood that a fraud is being perpetrated.
6. The investing public believes that any unsafe activities being carried out by the company would be exposed by the public accountant and would be exposed, so the investor does not inadvertently invest in unsafe activities.
7. A public accountant is expected to document and report unethical activities. An investor believes that his investment is of high quality since it has been audited by a public accountant.

The responsibilities that are given to the auditor by the law, especially the Sarbanes Oxley Act of 2002 goes to a great ...

Solution Summary

This explanation provides you a comprehensive argument relating to Public Accounting Profession

$2.19