Explore BrainMass

Positivism and Classical Criminology

This content was STOLEN from BrainMass.com - View the original, and get the already-completed solution here!

What impact have positivism and the classical school of criminology had on the basic structure of the criminal justice system and the focus of its policies? Review the following criminal justice strategies and explain whether they are more congruent with the ideas of positivism or the classical school:
- Three strikes laws
- Vocational training for offenders
- Mandatory minimum sentences
- The insanity defense
- The death penalty

Explain the specifics about the penalties that led to your opinion. In addition, explain whether you think most policies in the system have the goal of:
- Using punishment or threat of punishment to deter people from committing crime.
- Trying to prevent criminal behavior or correct and treat it once it occurs.

Use references cite sources.

© BrainMass Inc. brainmass.com October 25, 2018, 10:14 am ad1c9bdddf

Solution Preview


The classical school of criminology has had the greatest impact on the structure of criminal justice in the United States because it placates that the punishment should fit the crime and that people are only deterred from criminal behavior when punishment is in proportion to the criminal behavior committed. In contrast, positivism has been thoroughly refuted by theorists as the notion that how a person looks can determine if they will engage in crime is false and was predicated upon racist ideology. Rehabilitation of criminals can be attributed to positivism as the father of this ideology was an advocate for rehabilitating offenders as opposed to only punishing them for their behavior as he realized that punishment without rehabilitation would only ...

Solution Summary

This solution discusses issues related to positivism and classical criminology.

See Also This Related BrainMass Solution

Positivist school of criminology and classical criminology

Explain the differences between the positivist and the classical school of criminology regarding the causes of criminal behavior.
Analyze the impact that individual's environment and/or genetics have on the individual's ability to make a free choice not to commit criminal acts.
Explain whether all criminal behavior can be considered rational.
Identify the strengths and weaknesses of the positions of the police chief and the prison warden and explained with whom you agree. Analyzed whether positivist or classical policies have been used more in the criminal justice system.

Suggest the direction that criminal justice policies should take in the future.

View Full Posting Details