Explore BrainMass
Share

Cicero and the Law Student

This content was STOLEN from BrainMass.com - View the original, and get the already-completed solution here!

Discuss the two sides in this scenario, then choose one of them and justify your position.

What contradictions come into play?

Cicero agreed to teach a student law under the following conditions: the student would pay the first half of the fee at the beginning of the course, and the second half after he won his first case. However, following the completion of the course of study the student did not begin practicing law. Cicero suspected he was reneging on the second half of the fee, so he sued him in court.

Cicero argued that if the court decided in his favor, the student should pay him, and if the court decided against him, the student had won his first case and should pay him.

The student argued, however, that if the court decided in his favor, he should not have to pay, and if the court found against him, he had not won his first case and should not have to pay.

© BrainMass Inc. brainmass.com October 25, 2018, 6:52 am ad1c9bdddf
https://brainmass.com/english-language-and-literature/language/cicero-law-student-479345

Solution Preview

A beginning argument on the law student's side:

The law student should not have to pay, because he had not won any cases, as per the agreement. When Cicero argued in court, the first part of his argument was that the student should have to pay him, without including any conditions. However, in the second half of his argument, he states that if he loses the case, the student had won his first case and would owe him the money. Cicero is contradicting himself by ...

Solution Summary

Discuss the two sides in this scenario, then choose one of them and justify your position.

What contradictions come into play?

Cicero agreed to teach a student law under the following conditions: the student would pay the first half of the fee at the beginning of the course, and the second half after he won his first case. However, following the completion of the course of study the student did not begin practicing law. Cicero suspected he was reneging on the second half of the fee, so he sued him in court.

Cicero argued that if the court decided in his favor, the student should pay him, and if the court decided against him, the student had won his first case and should pay him.

The student argued, however, that if the court decided in his favor, he should not have to pay, and if the court found against him, he had not won his first case and should not have to pay.

$2.19
See Also This Related BrainMass Solution

Setting up a lesson plan

I am trying to set up a lesson plan, but need help to determine the following:

1. Which instructional functions are most effective with a target population?
2. What types of strategies can be used to motivate learners to be engaged in the instructional activity?
3. What factors contribute to the success of the strategies?

Thank you.

View Full Posting Details