The managers of your company are deciding whether to develop a brand new product not yet seen in the marketplace or a version of a competitor's product that has already been launched into the marketplace.
Management has called a meeting to discuss which way to go. They want to know if they should follow the "first-mover" theory or "late-mover" theory. You have been assigned the task to develop a neat and organized report for this meeting that will give evidence that describes and discusses either supports or disagrees with these theories. You may use the Library or other Web resources to find more information on these terms as well as examples to support your position.
As a new consultant, you really don't know much about the company involved, the potential products that the managers want to discuss in their meeting, nor the personalities of the managers who will be attending the meeting. The very best that you can really do within the given scenario is to thoroughly and factually explore both of these theories in your report as input for their discussion during the remainder of the meeting.
You should provide an unbiased comparison of the two theories.
Identify at least four advantages and four disadvantages for each theory and comprehensively show how each advantage or disadvantage affects the use of that theory (a minimum of 16 pros/cons in all).
Identify at least four examples of real firms who have been successful and four examples of real firms who have been failures using each theory (a minimum of 16 real firms in all).
Provide a definitive and unbiased recommendation of which theory to use. You should provide the specific attributes which constitute the most advantageous context in which the chosen theory operates and justify your recommendation with researched support, logic and examples.© BrainMass Inc. brainmass.com October 10, 2019, 2:43 am ad1c9bdddf
Decision Between First-Mover Theory and Late-Mover Theory
This paper contrasts "first-mover theory" vs. "late-mover theory". This paper will detail and explain the advantages and disadvantages of both concepts along with examples of companies who succeeded and those that failed at both. After you read the analysis within this paper, my findings and recommendations will be at the end of this document.
Would following the first-mover theory be the more effective way to build a new business or would just creating a new version with the late-mover theory be a more economical way to build a new business? The choice needs to be made and this paper will address that aspect.
This paper is to present research analysis about "first-mover theory" vs. "late-mover theory" in order for management to make an intelligent decision as to whether the company should develop a brand new product not yet seen in the marketplace or a version of a competitor's product that has already been launched into the marketplace. The first-mover has the advantage to capture market share more easily without having to worry about a competitor trying to do the same thing with the same product. The first-mover embarks on an action or strategy that will lead to better performance and profit. First-movers are pioneers in the area of business which include not only new products and new technology, but also new advertising designs.
FIRST OR LATE-MOVER THEORY
First Table-advantages of being a first-mover
Advantages of First-Mover Theory
- Ability to command premium pricing as no substitute is available
- Capture a higher market
- Establish benchmarks
- Network effects
- Ability to select the best distribution channel
- Acquisition of resources
- Establish switching costs for buyers to move to other brands, make life difficult for late movers.
- The first-mover has the ability to command pricing because there is no available substitute in the marketplace. Consumers are willing to pay a premium for products that haven't been out on the market.
- First-movers can capture greater market share since they are new.
- They establish benchmarks because there are none from before.
- Network effects apply to industries where the value of a good or service increases with the number of users. A first-mover's advantage can increase exponentially if he is able to effectively dominate a network early on (Lieberman and Montgomery, 1987)
- Acquisition of resources in the competitive market where there are scarce resources, a first-mover can benefit from acquiring the resources and assets first before their competitors (Lieberman and Montgomery, 1987).
- Consumer switching cost is beneficial if first-mover effectively captures the consumers early on (Lieberman and Montgomery, 1987).
Second Table- disadvantages of being first-mover
Disadvantages of the First-Mover Theory:
- High risk
- Free-rider effects
- Resolution of uncertainty
- First-mover inertia
- Consumer preference not available
- Market dynamics not available
- Great deal of risk introducing new products in the marketplace
- High risk if the first major disadvantage because information on trends, market dynamics, and what consumers will buy are not available for the first-mover.
- Free-rider effects have to do with the absence of patent protection because their product is newly designed.
- Resolution of uncertainty when a product or service is new. No one is sure how the product will be used and what it is about the product that consumers will find useful.
- First-move inertia happens when the consumer wants changes made and this happens. The first mover is not able to make the changes when the consumer wishes them done. Most times, consumers will then go with what was working before.
- Consumer preference is not available on new products so the first-mover is at a disadvantage as to how good this new product will be.
- Market dynamics are also not available so the same holds true that there is no marketing information to analyze the trends in consumer buying.
- In this economy, there is a tremendous risk in introducing a new product into the marketplace. All the money that would be invested to create a brand new product only to have it fail would be bad.
Third Table- successes using the first-mover theory
Successes Using the First-Mover ...