Good Samaritan: Moral obligation to save the drowning boy?
Not what you're looking for?
Roger Smith, a quite competent swimmer, is out for a leisurely stroll. During the course of his walk he passes by a deserted pier from which a teenage boy who apparently cannot swim has fallen into the water. The boy is screaming for help. Smith recognizes that there is absolutely no danger to himself if he jumps in to save the boy; he could easily succeed if he tried.
Nevertheless, he chooses to ignore the boy's cries. The water is cold and he is afraid of catching a cold -- he doesn't want to get his good clothes wet either. "Why should I inconvenience myself for this kid," Smith says to himself, and passes on.
Does Smith have a moral obligation to save the boy? If so, should he have a legal obligation ["Good Samaritan" laws] as well?
Website: http://www.friesian.com/valley/dilemmas.htm
Purchase this Solution
Solution Summary
Referring to the moral dilemma detailed on Website: http://www.friesian.com/valley/dilemmas.htm, I tackle the story of Roger Smith and whether he should have saved the boy drowning in the water.
I also include a reference that details information regarding Good Samaritan laws.
Solution Preview
Does Smith have a moral obligation to save the boy?
Quite possibly, the moral or ethical obligation here is the only one that Roger has in this situation. Even though he may be a 'quite competent swimmer', the text/story does not state that he is a lifeguard, doctor, nurse or similar person that may be required to perform such duties as part of his 'everyday' job. So, if he had been a lifeguard or paramedic (or similar), he may not necessarily have a legal obligation (though see note in second question below), but his moral duties would ...
Purchase this Solution
Free BrainMass Quizzes
Cost Concepts: Analyzing Costs in Managerial Accounting
This quiz gives students the opportunity to assess their knowledge of cost concepts used in managerial accounting such as opportunity costs, marginal costs, relevant costs and the benefits and relationships that derive from them.
Organizational Behavior (OB)
The organizational behavior (OB) quiz will help you better understand organizational behavior through the lens of managers including workforce diversity.
Basics of corporate finance
These questions will test you on your knowledge of finance.
Motivation
This tests some key elements of major motivation theories.
Business Ethics Awareness Strategy
This quiz is designed to assess your current ability for determining the characteristics of ethical behavior. It is essential that leaders, managers, and employees are able to distinguish between positive and negative ethical behavior. The quicker you assess a person's ethical tendency, the awareness empowers you to develop a strategy on how to interact with them.