Share
Explore BrainMass

Sam vs Victim & Tavern

Can you help me get started on this set of questions???

In violation of a local ordinance, Tavern serves alcohol to Sam, obviously intoxicated. Sam picks a fight with Victim, beating him severely. The fight is broken up. As Sam leaves the bar, Victim's friend, Payback, beats Sam in turn. Sam's staggers to his vehicle, drives off and runs over Pedestrian. He continues along until he runs into a utility pole, ending his evening with a lengthy hospitalization.

a. You represent Victim. Make your best argument as to why Tavern is liable to Victim for his injuries.
b. You represent Tavern. Make your best argument as to why Tavern is not liable to Victim for his injuries.
c. You represent Pedestrian. Make your best argument as to why Tavern is liable to Pedestrian for her injuries.
d. You represent Tavern. Make your best argument as to why Tavern is not liable to Pedestrian for her injuries.
e. You represent Sam. Make your best argument as to why Tavern is liable to Sam for his injuries from the beating by Payback.
f. You represent Tavern. Make your best argument as to why Tavern is not liable to Sam for his injuries from the beating by Payback.
g. You represent Sam. Make your best argument as to why Tavern is liable to Sam for his injuries when he struck the utility pole.
h. You represent Tavern. Make your best argument as to why Tavern is not liable to Sam for his injuries when he struck the utility pole.

Solution Preview

a. You represent Victim. Make your best argument as to why Tavern is liable to Victim for his injuries.
Tavern is responsible for injuries because Taverns served alcohol to Sam in contravention of the local laws. In addition, Tavern served liquor to Sam even though he was drunk. This fact was observable. The reason Victim was injured was that Same beat him up and Sam would not have beaten up Victim had Sam not been given alcohol in contravention of the local law.

b. You represent Tavern. Make your best argument as to why Tavern is not liable to Victim for his injuries.
Tavern is not liable to victim for his injuries because of several reasons. First, there is no direct contact between Tavern and Victim. The Victim has been beaten up by Sam and not by Tavern. Further, Tavern served alcohol to Sam without knowing that Sam was intoxicated. Also, Sam beat up Victim because of the fight and quarrel between Same and Victim and Tavern had nothing to do with it. There are several witnesses that will vouch that Sam knew victim and so fought with Victim and Tavern had nothing to do with that.

c. You represent Pedestrian. Make your best argument as to why Tavern is liable to Pedestrian for her injuries.
There are several reasons why Tavern is liable to Pedestrian for her injuries. The reasons ...

Solution Summary

This solution gives you a detailed discussion on Sam vs Victim & Tavern Arguments

$2.19