Probability problem marginal analysis
Not what you're looking for?
Working on below problem to identify error as presented.
"On the fictitious game show "Marginal Analysis for Everyone" the host subjects contestants to unusual tests of mental skill. On one, a contestant may choose one of two identical envelopes labeled A and B, each of which contains an unknown amount of money.
The host reveals, though that one envelope contains twice as much as the other. After choosing A, the host suggests that the contestant might want to switch.
"Switching is clearly advantageous." intones the host. "Suppose you have amount X in your envelope A. Then B must contain either x/2 (with probability .5) or 2x (with probability .5). thus, the expected value of switching is 1.25x. In fact now that I think about it, I'll only let you switch if you give me a 10% cut of your winnings. What do you say? You'll still be ahead."
"No deal," replies the contestant. "But I'll be happy to switch for free. In fact, I'll even let you choose which envelope I get. I won't even charge you anything."
What is wrong with the host's analysis?
Purchase this Solution
Solution Preview
Suppose the amount in envelops is Y and 2Y. Y=x/1.5 and 2Y=2x/1.5
The host is ignoring the fact that x is not a fixed number but a random variable with equal probabilities of ...
Purchase this Solution
Free BrainMass Quizzes
Measures of Central Tendency
This quiz evaluates the students understanding of the measures of central tendency seen in statistics. This quiz is specifically designed to incorporate the measures of central tendency as they relate to psychological research.
Measures of Central Tendency
Tests knowledge of the three main measures of central tendency, including some simple calculation questions.
Know Your Statistical Concepts
Each question is a choice-summary multiple choice question that presents you with a statistical concept and then 4 numbered statements. You must decide which (if any) of the numbered statements is/are true as they relate to the statistical concept.
Terms and Definitions for Statistics
This quiz covers basic terms and definitions of statistics.