# Mutually Exclusive Projects

This is a homework problem from ch. 10 of "Corporate Finance: A Focused Approach (2nd ed). Please use the attached template from same book Web site. I can not get same answers as given in class. Please explain steps/formulas, verbage etc in separate Word document if possible. Thank you.

question 10-18:

Gardial Fisheries is considering 2 mutually exclusive investments. The projects expected net cash flows are as follows:

expected net cash flows

year project a project b

0 ($375) ($575)

1 (300) 190

2 (200) 190

3 (100) 190

4 600 190

5 600 190

6 926 190

7 (200) 0

a. If each projects cost of capital was 12% which project should be selected? If cost of capital was 18% what would be the proper choice?

b. construct NPV profiles for proj a and b

c. what is each projects IRR?

d. what is the crossover rate, and what is its significance?

e. What is each project's MIRR at a cost of capital of 12%? At r = 18%? (period 7 is end of project b's life

https://brainmass.com/business/capital-budgeting/mutually-exclusive-projects-159579

#### Solution Preview

Please see the attached file. The cell formula will explain how the figures have been input.

a. If each projects cost of capital was 12% which project should be selected? If cost of capital was 18% what would be the proper choice?

We should select the project with a higher NPV. We calculate the NPV of the two projects, using the NPV function in excel. At 12% the NPV of A is higher and so should be selected. At 18% the NPV of B is higher ...

#### Solution Summary

Then solution explains how to evaluate two mutually exclusive projects.