Purchase Solution

The Fourth Amendment and The Exclusionary Rule

Not what you're looking for?

Ask Custom Question

Please help me so I can complete this assignment:

Write a letter in which you assume the role of any modern United States senator. Direct your letter to the Congress of the United States. In it, either defend the use of the exclusionary rule, or explain why the exclusionary rule was not intended to be used as an enforcement technique for violations of the Fourth Amendment.

In the letter:
Define the scope and limitations of the Fourth Amendment.
Explain what you think should happen if the police conduct an illegal search and seizure: Should the evidence be allowed or excluded from trial? Should police be granted certain exceptions in using illegally obtained evidence? Why or why not?
Identify and cite case examples that support your argument. You may use examples identified in Issue 4 of Debating Crime, or on the Internet.
If you argue that the exclusionary rule should be abolished, propose an alterative for deterring police misconduct.

Purchase this Solution
Solution Summary

In a letter to the Senator this solution gives you the scope of the Fourth Amendment in preventing illegal searches and seizures. It also describes the exclusionary rule and its effectiveness.

Solution Preview

Write a letter in which you assume the role of any modern United States senator. Direct your letter to the Congress of the United States. In it, either defend the use of the exclusionary rule, or explain why the exclusionary rule was not intended to be used as an enforcement technique for violations of the Fourth Amendment.

In the letter:
Define the scope and limitations of the Fourth Amendment:
The Fourth Amendment protects the right of the people to be secure in their person, houses, papers and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures. It also assures that warrants will be issued only on probable cause and will be supported by oath and the places that needs to be searched has to be described. The warrant also needs to describe the things or the persons that are to be seized.
The scope of the fourth amendment is that its applicability is limited to government officers and to criminal proceedings. The exclusionary rule is applied when evidence is obtained through a violation of the Fourth Amendment is declared not admissible by the prosecution during the defendant's criminal trial.
The use of the exclusionary rule is the most powerful way of enforcing the ...

Purchase this Solution
Free BrainMass Quizzes
Constitutional Law Rights

How much do you know about Constitutional Law Rights? Find out with this quiz!

Evidence

Do you know your evidence objections? Find out with this quiz!

Contract Requirments

How much do you know about the legal requirements for a contract? Find out with this quiz!

Criminal Defenses Review

Test your knowledge of the basics of criminal law and defenses with this quiz.

Title VII Laws

Learn the basics of the laws under Title VII.

View More Free Quizzes
Related BrainMass Solutions

  • Excllusionary Rule

    It is a fact that the exclusionary rule reduces the number of illegal searches and seizures and compels policemen to apply for warrants and follow the terms of the warrants. It is a rule of restitution and does not allow unjust enrichment.

  • Fourth Amendment vs. Polcie Power

    Defend the use of the exclusionary rule. In the letter: Define the scope and limitations of the Fourth Amendment.

  • Exclusionary Rule: Should it be Abolished

    The exclusionary rule can trace its origins to the fourth amendment, which protects us from illegal searches and seizures. Weeks v.

  • Exclusionary Rule - Evidence

    The rationale and purpose of the exclusionary rule is to prevent unjust and illegal arrests of American citizens and to protect the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments that pertain to unreasonable searches and seizures and the Equal Amendment.

  • The Exclusionary Rule and Searches and Seizures

    The court made Exclusionary Rule was established to exclude evidence obtained in violation of one's fourth amendment rights.

  • The Exclusionary Rule

    Fourth Amendment principles relating to search and seizure.

  • Exclusionary Rule in Probation and Parole

    523752 Exclusionary Rule in Probation and Parole The greatest aspect of the American judicial system is the wide range of courts that deal with certain criminal and civil lawsuits.

  • Search and Seizure & the Exclusionary Rule

    According to Lynch (n.d), much of the modern debate about the enforcement of the Fourth Amendment has focused on the wisdom of and constitutional necessity for the so-called exclusionary rule, under which evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment

  • Bill of Rights and Legal Restraints

    This rule was established by judges who thought that it would be unfair to allow police to infringe on the Fourth Amendment in order to obtain evidence.

View More Related Solutions